I only gave it four stars because I wish it were a little bit more narrow, but that really is personal. I do want to share that I have found that by stuffing one or sometimes two innersoles in a medium shoe that is cut high, as this one is, I am able to wear them. Those of you with narrow feet will understand that this is huge!! I especially like that it has the fine mesh lining. I think it makes it a little more comfortable. I would really, really prefer it to be a little bit darker, but I’m just happy I can wear it, and I will wear with every color pants and a couple of linen dresses all summer!